User:Ziggy
Ziggy can be contacted via email at ziggy.t@zeitgeistaustralia.org.
Contents |
Personal understanding of what an RBE is
This knowledge-base is proposing considering a Resource-Based Technology any socio-economic system that:
- requires all activities to be fully sustainable in the long term
- does not require money or barter to provide for all needs of human life
- aims at releasing humankind from all dangerous or tedious labour through the use of technology
Critique
Ziggy is openly critical of several characteristics of various advocates of RBE, and very critical of other forms of activism, charity and general society.
Critique on RBE advocates
Critique on TVP
Ziggy is critical of The Venus Project's structure and transition style for the following reasons:
- Structure
- Transition style
(Unfinished)
which would require collusion of nations and great power structures to implement a global RBE, imposing the new socio-economic system on unwilling minorities. Although imposition of socio-economic systems on minorities is the current norm, Ziggy reasons that a RBE would be dysfunctional in the existence of opposing minorities, mostly as a result of the RBE's expected lack of authority and government. Also, despite TVP's claim of having a comprehensive plan of transition, there doesn't seem to be any evidence that such plan exist in any way other than the text contents of their website. He criticises as well the vagueness of their published materials, like All resources become the common heritage of all of the inhabitants{{ safesubst:#ifeq:User|User
|
{{#switch:¬
|¬={{#if:
{{#ifeq: | true
| dontcat
}}{{#ifeq: | no
| dontcat
}}{{#switch: ¬
| yes
| ¬ =
| #default = dontcat
}}{{#switch:
| no =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage =
| subpage = dontcat
| subsubpage = dontcat
}}
| only =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage = dontcat
| subpage = | subsubpage = }}
}}
| |
{{#switch:
{{#ifeq: | false
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#if:x
|
{{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:| | User:Ziggy }}|0|2}}
|
|
}}
}}
}}
}}
}}
| hide =
| #default =
{{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |
|
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}}
|
{{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} }} | {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} | }}
}} }}
}}
|SUBST=
}}{{#if:
{{#ifeq: | true
| dontcat
}}{{#ifeq: | no
| dontcat
}}{{#switch: ¬
| yes
| ¬ =
| #default = dontcat
}}{{#switch: no
| no =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage =
| subpage = dontcat
| subsubpage = dontcat
}}
| only =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage = dontcat
| subpage = | subsubpage = }}
}}
| |
{{#switch:
{{#ifeq: | false
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#if:x
|
{{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:| | User:Ziggy }}|0|2}}
|
|
}}
}}
}}
}}
}}
| hide =
| #default =
{{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |{{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
|[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}
|
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}}
|
{{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
|[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}
| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} }} | {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
|[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}
| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} | }}
}} }}
}}{{#if:citation needed
|[{{#if:
|{{{pre-text}}}
}}citation needed{{#if:
| {{{post-text}}}
}}]|
}}{{#if:|}}
|{{subst:Unsubst|Citation needed| name|¬|reason|¬| date|{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}} }}
}} however there is no mention of how this could happen or be enforced, or in which way individuals' private property be transitioned to becoming common heritage.
Lack of definitions{{ safesubst:#ifeq:User|User
|
{{#switch:¬
|¬={{#if:
{{#ifeq: | true
| dontcat
}}{{#ifeq: | no
| dontcat
}}{{#switch: ¬
| yes
| ¬ =
| #default = dontcat
}}{{#switch:
| no =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage =
| subpage = dontcat
| subsubpage = dontcat
}}
| only =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage = dontcat
| subpage = | subsubpage = }}
}}
| |
{{#switch:
{{#ifeq: | false
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#if:x
|
{{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:| | User:Ziggy }}|0|2}}
|
|
}}
}}
}}
}}
}}
| hide =
| #default =
{{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |
|
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}}
|
{{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} }} | {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} | }}
}} }}
}}
|SUBST=
}}{{#if:
{{#ifeq: | true
| dontcat
}}{{#ifeq: | no
| dontcat
}}{{#switch: ¬
| yes
| ¬ =
| #default = dontcat
}}{{#switch: no
| no =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage =
| subpage = dontcat
| subsubpage = dontcat
}}
| only =
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|3}}
| subsubpage
| {{#if:{{#titleparts:User:Ziggy|0|2}}
| subpage
| basepage
}}
}}
}}
| basepage = dontcat
| subpage = | subsubpage = }}
}}
| |
{{#switch:
{{#ifeq: | false
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#ifeq: | yes
|
| {{#if:x
|
{{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:| | User:Ziggy }}|0|2}}
|
|
}}
}}
}}
}}
}}
| hide =
| #default =
{{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 | {{#if:Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification
|[[Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist:Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}
|
{{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}}
|
{{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = {{#if:Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification
|[[Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist:Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}
| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:|{{#ifeq:{{{name}}}|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} }} | {{#switch:
{{#if:
| {{{demospace}}}
| {{#if:
|
{{#ifeq:|
| talk
|
}}
|
{{#ifeq:user|user talk
| talk
| user
}}
}}
}}
| main | = {{#if:Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification
|[[Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist:Category:TZMWiki articles needing clarification from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
|[[ {{#if:
|from
}}]]{{#if:
|{{#ifexist: from |
|
}}
}}
}}
| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:|{{#ifeq:{{{name}}}|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =
}} | }}
}} }}
}}{{#if:examples needed
|[{{#if:
|{{{pre-text}}}
}}examples needed{{#if:
| {{{post-text}}}
}}]|
}}
|{{subst:Unsubst|Examples| pre-text|¬ | post-text|¬ | date|{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}} }}
}} for a Resource-Based Economy is particularly directed towards The Venus Project, who is the agent most concerned with its implementation and publicising. He also criticises the TVP's notion of global RBE, which appears to require nations to agree to the move, and therefore depends on the current Democratic processes; Jacque Fresco has himself criticised that the current system lacks a true Democracy, therefore it can be implied that a Resource-Based Economy will be imposed on everybody, whereas they voted for it or not.
