Difference between revisions of "RBEM/Implementation"

From MediaWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎Training Arena)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
There is no consent yet about how to implement the ideas of a [[Resource-Based Economic Model]]. Generally, there are two approaches: [[Bottom-Up Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy|bottom-up]] and [[Top-Down Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy|top-down]]. For the two general approaches there exist many potential variations, for example [[RBEM/Strategies for integration with the monetary market|different degrees of interaction with the monetary market in RBEM projects]] to interactions with the monetary system.
+
There is no consent yet about how to implement the ideas of a [[Resource-Based Economic Model]]. Generally, there are two approaches: [[Bottom-Up Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy|bottom-up]] and [[Top-Down Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy|top-down]]. For the two general approaches there exist many potential variations, for example [[RBEM/Strategies for integration with the monetary market]].
  
 +
== Bottom-up and Top-down approaches ==
 
Advocates of bottom-up approaches argue for starting with [[RBEM Implementation Projects|RBEM implementation projects]] soon, for incrementally developing the implemented methods and for incrementally increasing the participation, either on a individual basis or by including more and more people{{Cn}}. Advocates of top-down approaches rather think that people could be distracted from the general RBEM ideas because of problems that arise from specific RBEM implementation projects. They support educating as many people as possible and planning as many details as possible, before starting to implement a Resource-Based Economy{{Cn}}. Of course also hybrid approaches are conceivable.
 
Advocates of bottom-up approaches argue for starting with [[RBEM Implementation Projects|RBEM implementation projects]] soon, for incrementally developing the implemented methods and for incrementally increasing the participation, either on a individual basis or by including more and more people{{Cn}}. Advocates of top-down approaches rather think that people could be distracted from the general RBEM ideas because of problems that arise from specific RBEM implementation projects. They support educating as many people as possible and planning as many details as possible, before starting to implement a Resource-Based Economy{{Cn}}. Of course also hybrid approaches are conceivable.
  
−
== Pros and Cons of Bottom-Up Approaches ==
+
=== Pros and Cons of Bottom-Up Approaches ===
−
 
+
 
{{Main|Bottom-Up Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy}}
 
{{Main|Bottom-Up Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy}}
  
−
== Pros and Cons of Top-Down Approaches ==
+
=== Pros and Cons of Top-Down Approaches ===
−
 
+
 
{{Main|Top-Down Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy}}  
 
{{Main|Top-Down Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy}}  
−
 
−
Leaders rise naturally{{Vague}}{{Examples}}{{CN}}.
 
  
 
== Training Arena ==
 
== Training Arena ==

Revision as of 12:40, 26 February 2013

There is no consent yet about how to implement the ideas of a Resource-Based Economic Model. Generally, there are two approaches: bottom-up and top-down. For the two general approaches there exist many potential variations, for example RBEM/Strategies for integration with the monetary market.

Contents

Bottom-up and Top-down approaches

Advocates of bottom-up approaches argue for starting with RBEM implementation projects soon, for incrementally developing the implemented methods and for incrementally increasing the participation, either on a individual basis or by including more and more people{{ safesubst:#ifeq:| 

|

{{#switch:¬ 

|¬={{#if:
 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: 
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}} 

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }} 

 }}

| | 

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

| 


     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}} 

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |       
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} 

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} }} | {{#switch: 

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} | }} 

   }}
 }}

}} 

|SUBST=

}}{{#if: 

 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: no
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}} 

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }} 

 }}

| | 

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

| 


     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}} 

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |{{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}} 
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} 

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements 

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} }} | {{#switch: 

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements 

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} | }} 

   }}
 }}

}}{{#if:citation needed 

|[{{#if:
 |{{{pre-text}}} 
}}citation needed{{#if:
 | {{{post-text}}}
}}]|

}}{{#if:|}} 

|{{subst:Unsubst|Citation needed| name|¬|reason|¬| date|{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}} }}

}}. Advocates of top-down approaches rather think that people could be distracted from the general RBEM ideas because of problems that arise from specific RBEM implementation projects. They support educating as many people as possible and planning as many details as possible, before starting to implement a Resource-Based Economy{{ safesubst:#ifeq:| 

|

{{#switch:¬ 

|¬={{#if:
 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: 
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}} 

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }} 

 }}

| | 

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

| 


     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}} 

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |       
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} 

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} }} | {{#switch: 

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} | }} 

   }}
 }}

}} 

|SUBST=

}}{{#if: 

 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: no
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}} 

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }} 

 }}

| | 

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

| 


     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}} 

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |{{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}} 
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | = | talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} 

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements 

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} }} | {{#switch: 

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements 

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} | }} 

   }}
 }}

}}{{#if:citation needed 

|[{{#if:
 |{{{pre-text}}} 
}}citation needed{{#if:
 | {{{post-text}}}
}}]|

}}{{#if:|}} 

|{{subst:Unsubst|Citation needed| name|¬|reason|¬| date|{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}} }}

}}. Of course also hybrid approaches are conceivable.

Pros and Cons of Bottom-Up Approaches

{{#ifeq:|Category|The main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}} for this category {{#if:|are|is}}|Main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}}:}} Bottom-Up Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy{{#if: 
|{{#if:|, | and }}[[{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{3}}}|{{{3}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{4}}}|{{{4}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{5}}}|{{{5}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{6}}}|{{{6}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{7}}}|{{{7}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{8}}}|{{{8}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{9}}}|{{{9}}}]]}}{{#if:
|, and [[{{{10}}}|{{{10}}}]]}}{{#if: | (too many parameters in {{main}})}}

Pros and Cons of Top-Down Approaches

{{#ifeq:|Category|The main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}} for this category {{#if:|are|is}}|Main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}}:}} Top-Down Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy{{#if: 
|{{#if:|, | and }}[[{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{3}}}|{{{3}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{4}}}|{{{4}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{5}}}|{{{5}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{6}}}|{{{6}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{7}}}|{{{7}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{8}}}|{{{8}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{9}}}|{{{9}}}]]}}{{#if:
|, and [[{{{10}}}|{{{10}}}]]}}{{#if: | (too many parameters in {{main}})}}

Training Arena

{{#ifeq:|Category|The main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}} for this category {{#if:|are|is}}|Main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}}:}} /Training Arena{{#if: 
|{{#if:|, | and }}[[{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{3}}}|{{{3}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{4}}}|{{{4}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{5}}}|{{{5}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{6}}}|{{{6}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{7}}}|{{{7}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{8}}}|{{{8}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{9}}}|{{{9}}}]]}}{{#if:
|, and [[{{{10}}}|{{{10}}}]]}}{{#if: | (too many parameters in {{main}})}}

RBE Training Arenas (RBE-TAs) may be an option for enabling currently established communities to begin a gradual transformation into an RBE. With RBE-TAs developing all over a web of support for experimental settlements, settlements could be like graduate school.

External links

Retrieved from "https://rbem.org/wiki/index.php?title=RBEM/Implementation&oldid=1655"
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox