Difference between revisions of "RBEM/Implementation"

Revision as of 12:12, 26 February 2013

There is no consent yet about how to implement the ideas of a Resource-Based Economic Model. Generally, there are two approaches: bottom-up and top-down. For the two general approaches there exist many potential variations, for example RBEM/Strategies for integration with the monetary market.

Notable people

The transition is the process of transitioning into a global RBE. This page is for all relevant ideas and methods regarding it.

Oskar Gonzalez

Oskar Gonzalez<ref>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2Bkz-qDOOg</ref> makes the case that the monetary system is just an emergant property. He makes the analogy of a baseball game. That the baseball game only exists for as long as the players want to play. If the players all get hungry and go off and have lunch. The baseball game no longer exists. He uses this analogy to demonstrate how in the same way, the monetary system only exists if there are enough players who want to play the game.

He also makes the argument that we already have a resource based economy with our friends and family. The problem is simply that on the global scale when we interact with strangers we operate under the monetary based economy<ref>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCVMmhoWwrM</ref>.

Micro resource based economies exist all over the place, the problem is a lack of networking and connection between them that stops a true community RBE forming<ref>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VF__Gr6NSE0</ref>.

Peter Joseph

Peter Joseph makes 5 key points near the end of the first part of his lecture on the transition and in the beginning of the second part<ref>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIboEybWYW0</ref>.

The market beast is debt and everyone out there needs to do whatever they can to get out of debt.
The transition does not change the end goal. To illustrate this point he uses the example of needing to go to a

store to get a dire medical perscription. You would not shrug it off just because you forgot the directions. We know what the goal is and that the goal is needed.

We are always going to be in some kind of transition<ref>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PN3Ty9zgGOs</ref>.
We are not specifically out to get rid of police, in the same way we are not specifically out to get rid of

government. We argue that the closer we are to a true RBE, the less and less need there will be for police and government and law.

No single country can create a true global RBE on it's own because a true RBE is based on planetary management.

Bottom-up and Top-down approaches

Advocates of bottom-up approaches argue for starting with RBEM implementation projects soon, for incrementally developing the implemented methods and for incrementally increasing the participation, either on a individual basis or by including more and more people{{ safesubst:#ifeq:|

{{#switch:¬

|¬={{#if:
 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: 
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}}

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }}

}}

| |

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

|

     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}}

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |       
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}}

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}} }} | {{#switch:

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}} | }}

   }}
 }}

}}

|SUBST=

}}{{#if:

 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: no
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}}

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }}

}}

| |

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

|

     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}}

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |{{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}} 
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}}

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} }} | {{#switch:

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} | }}

   }}
 }}

}}{{#if:citation needed

|^{[{{#if:
 |{{{pre-text}}} 
}}citation needed{{#if:
 | {{{post-text}}}
}}]}|

}}{{#if:|}}

|{{subst:Unsubst|Citation needed| name|¬|reason|¬| date|{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}} }}

}}. Advocates of top-down approaches rather think that people could be distracted from the general RBEM ideas because of problems that arise from specific RBEM implementation projects. They support educating as many people as possible and planning as many details as possible, before starting to implement a Resource-Based Economy{{ safesubst:#ifeq:|

{{#switch:¬

|¬={{#if:
 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: 
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}}

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }}

}}

| |

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

|

     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}}

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |       
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}}

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}} }} | {{#switch:

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}} | }}

   }}
 }}

}}

|SUBST=

}}{{#if:

 {{#ifeq:  | true
 | dontcat    
 }}{{#ifeq:  | no
 | dontcat
 }}{{#switch: ¬
 | yes
 | ¬   =   
 | #default = dontcat   
 }}{{#switch: no
 | no = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage =

| subpage = dontcat

| subsubpage = dontcat

}}

 | only = 
   {{#switch:
 {{#if:
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|3}}
   | subsubpage    
   | {{#if:{{#titleparts:RBEM/Implementation|0|2}}
     | subpage
     | basepage
     }}
   }}
 }}

| basepage = dontcat

| subpage = | subsubpage = }}

}}

| |

 {{#switch:
   {{#ifeq:  | false
   |   
   | {{#ifeq:  | yes
     |   
     | {{#ifeq:  | yes
       |   
       | {{#if:x

|

     {{#if:{{#titleparts:{{#if:|  | RBEM/Implementation }}|0|2}}
     | 
        
          
            
              
                
                       
                 
               
             
           
         
       
     | 
             
       
     }}

}}

       }}
     }}
   }}
 | hide = 
 | #default  = 
   {{#ifeq: h0#384!5nea+w9 |{{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements
 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}} 
   | 
     {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

}}

   | 
     {{#iferror: {{#expr: 1 + {{#switch:
 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} }} | {{#switch:

 {{#if: 
   | {{{demospace}}}
   | {{#if: 
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     | 
       {{#ifeq:|talk
       | talk
       |  
       }}
     }}
   }}

| main | ={{#if:Category:Articles with unsourced statements

 |[[Category:Articles with unsourced statements {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist:Category:Articles with unsourced statements from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}{{#if:|}}{{#if:
 |[[ {{#if:
  |from 
 }}]]{{#if:
  |{{#ifexist: from |
   |
  }}
 }}
}}

| talk = | user = | wikipedia = | file | image = | mediawiki = | template = {{#if:Citation needed|{{#ifeq:Citation needed|||{{#if:||}}}}}} | help = | category = | portal = | book = | other | #default =

}} | }}

   }}
 }}

}}{{#if:citation needed

|^{[{{#if:
 |{{{pre-text}}} 
}}citation needed{{#if:
 | {{{post-text}}}
}}]}|

}}{{#if:|}}

|{{subst:Unsubst|Citation needed| name|¬|reason|¬| date|{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}} }}

}}. Of course also hybrid approaches are conceivable.

Pros and Cons of Bottom-Up Approaches

{{#ifeq:|Category|The main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}} for this category {{#if:|are|is}}|Main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}}:}} Bottom-Up Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy{{#if:

|{{#if:|, | and }}[[{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{3}}}|{{{3}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{4}}}|{{{4}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{5}}}|{{{5}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{6}}}|{{{6}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{7}}}|{{{7}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{8}}}|{{{8}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{9}}}|{{{9}}}]]}}{{#if:

|, and [[{{{10}}}|{{{10}}}]]}}{{#if: | (too many parameters in {{main}})}}

Pros and Cons of Top-Down Approaches

{{#ifeq:|Category|The main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}} for this category {{#if:|are|is}}|Main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}}:}} Top-Down Implementation of a Resource-Based Economy{{#if:

|{{#if:|, | and }}[[{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{3}}}|{{{3}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{4}}}|{{{4}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{5}}}|{{{5}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{6}}}|{{{6}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{7}}}|{{{7}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{8}}}|{{{8}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{9}}}|{{{9}}}]]}}{{#if:

|, and [[{{{10}}}|{{{10}}}]]}}{{#if: | (too many parameters in {{main}})}}

Training Arena

{{#ifeq:|Category|The main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}} for this category {{#if:|are|is}}|Main {{#ifeq:||article|page}}{{#if:|s}}:}} /Training Arena{{#if:

|{{#if:|, | and }}[[{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{3}}}|{{{3}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{4}}}|{{{4}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{5}}}|{{{5}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{6}}}|{{{6}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{7}}}|{{{7}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{8}}}|{{{8}}}]]}}{{#if:
|{{#if:|, |, and }}[[{{{9}}}|{{{9}}}]]}}{{#if:

|, and [[{{{10}}}|{{{10}}}]]}}{{#if: | (too many parameters in {{main}})}}

RBE Training Arenas (RBE-TAs) may be an option for enabling currently established communities to begin a gradual transformation into an RBE. With RBE-TAs developing all over a web of support for experimental settlements, settlements could be like graduate school.

External links

Sustainability Showcase: Platform to connect sustainability projects and organisations (http://www.sustainabilitysc.org/)
Transition Network: Network for initiatives to rebuild resilience and reduce CO₂ emissions (http://www.transitionnetwork.org/)
Ecology-minded villages: http://crystalwaters.org.au/, https://sites.google.com/site/ecodigsbris/
Freeconomy: Sharing platform (http://www.justfortheloveofit.org/)
Crealiity: Social semantic web to match desires and resources (currently only available in German) (http://crealiity.com/)
Time Banking platforms: https://www.timebanking.com.au/
Permaculture: http://www.permaculture.org.au/, http://www.urbanharvest.org/permaculture/resources.html, http://www.northeystreetcityfarm.org.au/
Living off-grid: http://www.off-grid.net/

References

1 }}

     | references-column-width 
     | references-column-count references-column-count-{{#if:1|{{{1}}}}} }}
   | {{#if: 
     | references-column-width }} }}" style="{{#if: 
   | {{#iferror: {{#ifexpr: 1 > 1 }}
     | Template:Column-width
     | -moz-column-count: {{#if:1|{{{1}}}}}; -webkit-column-count: {{#if:1|{{{1}}}}}; column-count: {{#if:1|{{{1}}}}}; }}
   | {{#if: 
     | Template:Column-width }} }} list-style-type: {{#switch: 
   | upper-alpha
   | upper-roman
   | lower-alpha
   | lower-greek
   | lower-roman = {{{group}}}
   | #default = decimal}};">

Unknown extension tag "references"

@@ Line 49: / Line 49: @@
 * [[Permaculture]]: http://www.permaculture.org.au/, http://www.urbanharvest.org/permaculture/resources.html, http://www.northeystreetcityfarm.org.au/
 * [[Living off-grid]]: http://www.off-grid.net/
+== References ==
+{{reflist}}

Difference between revisions of "RBEM/Implementation"

Revision as of 12:12, 26 February 2013

Contents

Notable people

Oskar Gonzalez

Peter Joseph

Bottom-up and Top-down approaches

Pros and Cons of Bottom-Up Approaches

Pros and Cons of Top-Down Approaches

Training Arena

External links

References

Personal tools

Namespaces

Variants

Views

Actions

Search

Navigation

Toolbox